The Evolution from Passwords to Passkeys: A Transformation in Security

In the realm of digital security, the transition from traditional password-based authentication to cutting-edge passkey technology is akin to upgrading from an old, reliable diesel car to a sleek, high-tech electric vehicle. Just as a new car offers a transformative driving experience, passkeys provide a secure, efficient, and modern approach to authentication. Let’s delve into the details and explore this shift thoroughly!

For years, passwords have been the cornerstone of digital authentication, much like that old diesel car that keeps chugging along. However, just like an aging vehicle, passwords come with their own set of issues. From compromised credentials to password reuse across multiple accounts, the vulnerabilities associated with passwords are glaring warning signs of the need for a change.

Research indicates that nearly half of all security incidents involve compromised passwords, highlighting the urgent need for a more robust authentication method. Enter passkeys, the high-tech equivalent of a bullet car in the authentication world. Faster, sleeker, and virtually impervious to attacks, passkeys offer a smoother and more secure authentication experience.

For organizations adhering to the ISO/IEC 27001 standard, transitioning from passwords to passkeys is not just an upgrade; it’s a comprehensive overhaul of security protocols. It requires meticulous alignment with established controls, risk management strategies, and documentation requirements to ensure a seamless transition.

The Technical Foundations of Passwordless Authentication

At the core of passwordless authentication is the elimination of the need to remember passwords. Instead, authentication relies on cryptographic keys, biometrics, or possession-based factors such as hardware tokens. Passkeys, built on FIDO2 and WebAuthn standards, exemplify this approach, providing a secure and reliable way to authenticate users.

When a user creates a passkey, their device generates a unique cryptographic key pair: a private key stored securely on the device and a public key registered with the service. During authentication, the service sends a challenge, the device signs it with the private key, and the service verifies the signature. This secure exchange ensures that the private key never leaves the user’s device, making it extremely difficult for attackers to intercept or phish.

Passkeys typically meet the Authenticator Assurance Level (AAL) 2 or 3 requirements as defined by NIST’s Digital Identity Guidelines, representing a significant advancement in security compared to traditional password-based authentication methods.

Modern passkeys come in two forms: device-bound, which are stored on hardware tokens like security keys, and syncable, which are backed up across devices through encrypted cloud services. The latest guidance from NIST acknowledges the importance of syncable authenticators, recognizing the need for robust access recovery mechanisms in case of device loss.

The adoption of passkeys is rapidly gaining momentum, with billions of online accounts already supporting this authentication method. Major tech giants like Amazon and Google have embraced passkeys, signaling a shift towards a more secure and user-friendly authentication paradigm.

Meeting ISO/IEC 27001 Compliance Requirements

ISO/IEC 27001 serves as a comprehensive framework for managing information security risks, guiding organizations through a complex landscape of security challenges. Authentication, a critical aspect of information security, is addressed through specific controls outlined in the standard.

Key controls related to authentication in ISO/IEC 27001 include:

• Annex A 5.15 (Access Control): Establishing rules and rights for accessing information and systems, including user authentication, authorization, and access provisioning.

• Annex A 5.17 (Authentication Information): Defining procedures for managing authentication credentials and protecting authentication data.

• Annex A 8.5 (Secure Authentication): Specifying technical requirements for secure authentication, including multi-factor authentication for privileged access.

For organizations certified under ISO/IEC 27001, the adoption of passkeys necessitates demonstrating compliance with existing control objectives, conducting thorough risk assessments, and documenting the implementation of the new authentication method.

Aligning Passwordless Adoption with ISO/IEC 27001 Controls

The transition to passkeys involves considerations across multiple ISO/IEC 27001 controls. Here’s how organizations can align their implementation with key controls:

A 5.15 (Access Control)

• Define the scope of passkeys based on risk levels, utilizing device-bound passkeys for privileged accounts and syncable passkeys for standard users.

• Document fallback procedures for device loss scenarios to ensure continuity of access.

• Establish clear policies for authenticating users without passkeys during transition periods.

A 5.17 (Authentication Information)

• Document the complete enrollment process, including registration initiation and identity verification steps.

• Define encryption requirements for storing public keys in databases to safeguard authentication data.

• Specify triggers for re-enrollment, such as device compromise or security incidents.

• Establish access controls for managing authentication data securely.

A 8.5 (Secure Authentication)

• Demonstrate compliance with multi-factor authentication by showcasing how passkeys provide two factors of authentication.

• Explain how cryptographic binding to specific domains enhances security and prevents phishing attacks.

• Detail the technical implementation of WebAuthn protocols and FIDO2 standards to meet secure authentication requirements.

Risk Assessment and Treatment

• Document the risks eliminated by transitioning to passkeys, such as credential theft and brute force attacks.

• Address new risks introduced by passkey adoption, such as device loss and recovery complexity.

• Establish monitoring procedures to detect and respond to emerging attack vectors effectively.

Organizations should prioritize the use of device-bound passkeys for privileged accounts and syncable passkeys for standard users to meet compliance requirements effectively. Documenting fallback procedures, encryption standards, and re-enrollment triggers is crucial for satisfying audit criteria.

The Benefits of Passkeys

Real-world implementation data underscores the advantages of passkeys beyond theoretical security models. Google’s experience with passkeys reveals a complete elimination of password-based attacks for accounts exclusively using passkeys, along with improved authentication success rates and faster sign-in times.

Managing passwords incurs ongoing operational costs, with help desk calls for password resets and account lockouts adding to the administrative burden. Password-related issues contribute significantly to help desk calls, costing organizations time and resources. By shifting to passkeys, organizations can mitigate these costs and enhance operational efficiency.

Microsoft’s adoption of passkeys as the default sign-in method for new accounts highlights the industry’s move towards reducing support burdens associated with password management. Passkeys align with various compliance requirements, including NIST AAL2/AAL3 standards, PCI DSS multi-factor authentication, GDPR data protection mandates, and SOC 2 access control requirements.

Challenges and Misconceptions

While passkeys offer enhanced security, their implementation comes with challenges that organizations need to address. Just as an electric vehicle requires modern infrastructure and support systems, passkeys demand a robust ecosystem for effective deployment.

Passkeys Aren’t Completely Phishing-Proof

Despite their security benefits, passkeys are not immune to attacks. Downgrade attacks, device code phishing, and OAuth consent attacks pose risks to passkey security. Organizations must monitor for such attacks, disable password fallback options, and educate users on recognizing suspicious authentication flows.

Account Recovery Complexity

In the event of a lost device, users may face challenges in recovering their passkeys. Recovery options such as email-based recovery, backup passkeys, manual verification, and recovery codes should be implemented to address this complexity effectively.

Mixed Authentication Environments

During transition periods, organizations may operate in mixed authentication environments, with some users using passkeys while others rely on passwords. This scenario can lead to inconsistencies in security posture, policy enforcement challenges, audit trail complexities, and user confusion. Organizations must navigate these challenges effectively during the transition to passkeys.

Enterprise Implementation Considerations

Enterprise password management platforms should support:

• WebAuthn-based authentication using fingerprint readers, Face ID, PIN codes, and hardware security keys.

• Flexible authentication policies to enforce passwordless authentication for specific user groups while maintaining password-based authentication for others during the transition phase.

• Email verification and authentication mechanisms to ensure secure account recovery processes.

• Audit trails and monitoring capabilities to track authentication events, passkey registrations, and modifications.

These capabilities enable organizations to transition gradually to passkeys while upholding ISO/IEC 27001 compliance standards.

Best Practices for Implementation

• Prioritize implementation based on risk levels, starting with privileged accounts and documenting the rationale for prioritization.

• Maintain a defense-in-depth approach by integrating passkeys into a comprehensive security strategy that includes session management and device security measures.

• Plan the transition meticulously by defining migration timelines, deadlines for passkey adoption, and clear communication with users.

• Proactively address account recovery challenges by implementing multiple recovery options, testing procedures regularly, and monitoring recovery usage.

• Thoroughly document the implementation process, technical architecture, policy updates, risk assessments, and training materials to demonstrate compliance with ISO/IEC 27001 requirements.

Embracing the Future of Authentication

While traditional password-based authentication still serves its purpose, organizations must adapt to the changing landscape of cybersecurity. Passkeys offer a fundamental shift in authentication security, delivering tangible benefits in terms of security, user experience, and operational efficiency.

By adopting passkeys, organizations can reduce the support burden associated with password management, align with various compliance frameworks, and enhance overall security posture. Embracing passkeys as a modern authentication method requires a strategic approach, meticulous documentation, and thoughtful management of the transition process.

If you’re ready to strengthen your authentication security, consider integrating Passwork as your password manager. With enterprise-grade passkey support, centralized credential management, and secure sharing capabilities, Passwork is designed to meet ISO/IEC 27001 compliance requirements effectively.

Take the next step towards improved security with Passwork: benefit from free migration assistance, implementation support, and a 20% discount when you’re ready to make the switch.

Experience the power of effective password management with Passwork. Start your free trial today!

This article is sponsored and written by Passwork.